"If you were a TV show, what TV show would you be and why?"
From an HR point of view I'd be concerned about a question of this nature. If the candidate is declined on the basis of this question and the potential employer cannot provide a sound legal basis for declination then an employment tribunal may take a dim view. The question would not appear to provide such a basis.
From the candidate's point of view the question lacks objectivity and relevance.
If the candidate is from a different ethnic background to the interviewer and answers with a TV show specific to their culture/gender (eg Asian Eye, GayTV) and is declined purely on this basis there are grounds for discrimination. Furthermore given those answers and a possible cultural void, the interviewer is none the wiser regarding skills, thus nothing significant has been added.
Some candidates will not see the relevance of the question and may react negatively towards its inclusion.
The question itself is abtract and unfocussed, it does not direct the candidates abilities or skills significantly it merely highlights a programme and asks the candidates themselves to justify why they ought to be that programme. Whilst this may highlight creativity, use of logic, reasoning and influencing skills, it doesnt cope adequately with objection handling techniques, matching, closing, resilience, questioning techniques, motivation, target setting, vigour, structure, clarity, rapport building, powers of expression, confidence, assertiveness etc all of which are highly desirable skills and qualities in a salesperson.
Furthermore there are plenty of good salesperson who are not quick thinkers, logical or creative or funny, they rely on other skills (and experience) and an employer may miss them. To reiterate as an employer you must have and be able to justify a sound legal basis for declination and your process must be fair to all.
If you want to find out what type of person they are and match that to the job description then there are many psychometrics or SHL or other tests you could use.
Competency based assessments including structured interviews and role plays are becoming very popular in probing for specific competencies and are rapidly becoming HR best practice in the assessment of skills and behaviours.
Recruitment has moved on considerably from the "sell me yourself" questions. |